Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Customers injured in crush suing Wal-Mart

NEW YORK (CNN) -- Two customers are suing Wal-Mart for negligence after being injured in a mad rush for post-Thanksgiving bargains that left one store employee dead, the men's attorney said Tuesday.

Temporary Wal-Mart worker Jdimytai Damour, 34, was crushed to death as he and other employees attempted to unlock the doors of a store on Long Island at 5 a.m. Friday.

Attorney Kenneth Mollins said Fritz Mesadieu and Jonathan Mesadieu were "literally carried from their position outside the store" and are now "suffering from pain in their neck and their back from being caught in that surge of people" that rushed into the Wal-Mart.

New York Newsday reported that the Mesadieus are father and son, ages 51 and 19.

The lawsuit alleges that the Mesadieus' injuries were a result of "carelessness, recklessness, negligence."

In a claim against the Nassau County police department, the men also contend that they "sustained monetary losses as a result of health care and legal expenses ... in the sum of $2 million."

"This is a tragic situation that could have and should have been avoided with the exercise of reasonable care. There are very simple measures that could have been put in place to avoid this, such as barriers along the line to spread people out, extra security and a better police presence," Mollins said.

He said his clients and others who were at the scene contend that the police "were there ... saw what was happening, and they left."

Calls seeking comment from Wal-Mart Stores Inc. were not immediately returned.

Lt. Kevin Smith of the Nassau County Police Department said, "it's our policy that we don't comment on open litigations" and would not respond directly to Mollins and his clients' claim that officers left the scene.

He said it is "incumbent upon the store to provide security" but noted that there was no security force present when officers responded to an initial phone call after 3 a.m. Friday for an unknown disturbance at the site.

Smith said the officers noticed a lack of order with the crowd and began to organize them into a line, remaining on site for about 30 minutes until the crowd had become orderly.

Throughout the morning, officers went back to check on the crowd and continued to notice no disturbance, Smith said.

He said that there were no additional calls for assistance until about 5 a.m., when people began rushing the doors of the store and trampled Damour.

An autopsy showed that Damour died of asphyxiation after being trampled, Nassau County officials have said.

Video showed that as many as a dozen people were knocked to the floor in the stampede of people trying to get into the store. The employee was "stepped on by hundreds of people" as other workers attempted to fight their way through the crowd, said Nassau County Police Detective Lt. Michael Fleming.


Another poignant example of why I hate people.

I'll bet you my butt that not a single one of these assholes will ever face a criminal charge for participating in this absolutely inexcusable display of the most base of human behavior. How could they? How do you pick someone out of a crowd like this to be responsible for its behavior? Meanwhile, a few of them will sue Walmart and score a couple million dollars for their effort.

It is reported that when Walmart employees and police tried to clear people out of the store, telling them that someone had been killed in their stampede, many balked, justifying their obstinance by crying "no way! we've been in line for hours!"

There is no defending that. Ever. And yes, Wal-Mart could have used 50 police officers, concertina wire, tazers, and attack dogs to keep the crowd ruly. More could have been done beyond the meager handful of security and police officers that were already there to maintain order. But the blame, as far as I am concerned, should rest squarely on the shoulders of anyone who, for even one moment, put their place in line above the welfare of their fellow human beings. 


1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I would agree whole-heartedly, though I would not let Wal-Mart off the hook so easily. I am hoping that there are some sort of criminal charges brought against both Wal-Mart and the individual shoppers that rushed the store. Short of that, it would be nice to see a civil suit against both groups.

I think this is entirely possible. Wal-Mart has video cameras everywhere. No, mostly they use it for stop-loss and union-busting activities, and it might be a struggle to get the tapes from them, but I am willing to bet that there is video of the event. Identifying the people that rushed in wouldn't be impossible, just difficult.

Again, I do think that Wal-Mart is culpable as well. For special events like this lots of stores have better planning and crowd control systems. People are given tickets for entry and only a few people are let in at a time. Extra security is hired. Th point is, if you are going to create a fervor you need to try to control it. Wal-Mart knows that there will be a rush, and their plan seems to be to tell those one or two guys working the door to open the gates and jump out of the way. Nice crowd control and safety procedures.

Now, to link to another post we debated, you can damn sure bet if Wal-Mart were unionized there would have been 16 security guards with cattle prods, concertina wire, and some semblance of a plan to protect employees. It might have been overkill, and it might have cost a ton, but no one would be dead.

I think the charges for everyone involved are something like criminal negligence.